The reason that we have social rules is to restrain those who create trouble. However, when we have Dharma, such rules are not needed. This was the basic message of the text called On Why Monks Do Not Bow Down Before Kings (沙門不敬王者論) written by Lu Shan Hui Yuan in China in the year 404. Of course, some rules are purely for convenience and are essentially etiquette designed to maintain order and civility within a group. They have no moral content. However, there are some slippery border areas here. Maintaining order may mean maintaining oppression or protecting a status quo that is cruel or deceitful. Then, although the rule itself is merely conventional, it is a convention in support of an immoral system and breaking the rule may be one way of demonstrating against the system. A recent example might be the American sportsman who refused to stand for the national anthem as a protest against racial discrimination in the country. The rule itself - standing for the anthem - is not iniquitous, but breaking it was one way of making a point.

Dharma should make most rules redundant. A Dharmic society should not need to be much concerned with 'crime' and certainly not with punishment. However, people are people and in any group of humans it seems to be virtually inevitable that conflicts and divisions arise. When there is plenty of space, this is not much of a problem - groups that want to live differently can simply go somewhere else and do so. Schism, in such circumstances, is not the end of the world and may be the beginning of peace. There is no absolute reason why we should all be nor do the same.When this is not practical, the problem is more difficult.

Of course, there are extremes. There is a value in compromise and also in accommodating the preferences of others, so long as they are not evil. People who follow Dharma are relatively easy to get along with in some ways because they see such differences as trivial and do not get het up about them. On the other hand, to most conventional people the Dharma practitioner may seem awkward because he or she does not readily follow the tramlines of society laid down by materialism, consumerism, status and security seeking and the general soap opera of conventional life. The Buddha quite plainly said that there is no nirvana to be found within the conventional life, that in order to follow Dharma one has to 'go forth' from it into the 'homelessness'.

Hui Yuan is generally regarded as the first supreme priest of Pure Land Buddhism in China. He started a society for the practice of contemplation of Amitabha Buddha. However, even Hui Yuan decided at one point that he had to expel a member because he always turned up drunk and made trouble for other members. There is a precept in Buddhism against getting inebriated. However, perhaps we should not see this incident as the application of a rule so much as a case of dealing with a situation in a one-off manner. The drunk was tolerated for quite a while before Hui Yuan drew the line. Whatever rules one has one still has to deal with instances one by one. Absolute rules tend to involve a cruelty of their own and so are, in general, to be avoided, if possible.

The general point is that the Dharma practitioner (and any truly religious person) has a reference point that transcends the worldly one and that is his or her true refuge. It matters not that an injunction or decision may be the result of a vote, legal process, ancient tradition, or judgement by a respected authority, if it is right it is right and if it is wrong it is wrong and the practitioner cannot avoid responsibility for his own decision. "I was just following orders" or "But we have a procedure" is no ultimate justification. While there are innumerable occasions in which it does no good to flout convention and there is no harm in following it, in the last analysis it is Dharma that matters.

Views: 93


ITZI Conference 2019

Subscribe to ITZI Conference Newsletter

* indicates required

Blog Posts

Sagesse féline...

Posted by Tamuly Annette on September 29, 2019 at 12:00 1 Comment

En l'absence de Darmavidya, j'ai - en ma qualité de voisine et d'amie - le privilège de m'occuper (un peu) de Tara, la petite chatte. C'est un bonheur  de la voir me faire la fête chaque fois que je me rends à Eleusis: elle s'étire, se roule sur le dos au soleil ou saute sur mes genoux. J'ignore si elle a profité de l'enseignement du maître des lieux, mais j'ai comme l'impression qu'elle me donne une belle leçon de sagesse: elle…



Posted by David Brazier on August 20, 2019 at 21:38 2 Comments

At the moment I am feeling very sad for the state of the planet. As I write the great forests are being consumed by fire, both the tropical forest in Brazil and the tundra forest in Russia. The great forests are the lungs of the earth. I myself have lung problems. When there are parts of the lungs that don’t work anymore one can run out of energy. It can strike suddenly. We will probably not do anything serious about climate change or wildlife extinction…



Posted by David Brazier on June 26, 2019 at 18:04 10 Comments

My medical condition continues to be a mystery. It is clear that I do not have any of the big nasty things - brain tumour, cracked skull, stroke, etc - as these have been ruled out by MRI investigation. Nonetheless I continue to have persistent, continuous head pain that varies in intensity and I become exhausted by the least effort so that I am functioning like an invalid incapable of doing very much. There is always a possibility that the whole syndrome is a…



Posted by Dayamay Dunsby on June 2, 2019 at 1:02 4 Comments

“Do we know what it means to be struck by grace? It does not mean that we suddenly believe that God exists, or that Jesus is the saviour, or that the Bible contains the truth. Grace strikes us when we are in great pain and restlessness. It strikes us when we walk through the dark Valley of a meaningless and empty life. It strikes us when we feel that our separation is deeper than usual, because we have violated another life, a life which we loved, or from which we were estranged. It strikes us… Continue

© 2019   Created by David Brazier.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service