In today’s teaching I would like to look critically at some of the principles, often taken as self-evident, that underpin much of our thinking about ethics.

There is, for instance, the so called golden rule, treat others as you would yourself be treated. This is closely related to the idea that one should only act upon maxims that one would wish were universal laws.

Then there is the imperative to be consistent in one’s beliefs and actions and make similar evaluations about similar cases, to practise what you preach and the general principle that to will the end is to will the means. All these general principles tend to go together and support one another.

While all of these principles can be useful in a “rule of thumb” way, there are many exceptions in real life. Mostly, for instance, we each want to be treated as a special case. We do not want to be treated in the same way as everybody else, and the fact that the wife likes lipstick does not indicate that it would make a good present for the husband. Furthermore, in the practical conduct of life, inconsistency is sometimes the best policy. 

There are, in fact, no ethical rules that fit all cases and not even any meta-level principles that can reliably determine how an ethical principle should be formed. Logic is extremely useful for analysing ethical arguments, and it is valuable to know how to do such analysis. Nonetheless, logic alone cannot tell us what it is best to do.

How is it then that we can have vows and precepts in our systems of spiritual training? When there is an ordination ceremony and we hear the candidate give assent to more than a hundred such maxims, it is frequently the case that many people in the room are deeply moved. The precepts seem to conjure up a picture of an ideal person in an ideal world and somewhere, deep within ourselves, we each unconsciously cleave to such an ideal world. It feels like our true home. The ritual gives form and voice to a profound longing within us which, most of the time, we keep shut away in a locked box hidden in our heart.

In fact, in practical terms, the precepts are impossible to keep strictly here in this world of conditions, but we feel that the attempt is elevating and improving. When one finds that one has fallen short on some principle, there is then something important to reflect upon. From such reflection one learns about oneself, about life, and about the world. One examines the gap between the ideal and the actual. 

The precepts are really an object of worship. They indicate the ideal and having this in mind inspires. 

When it comes to living the life within such inspiration, one still has to make unique decisions in unique situations as they come along. Sometimes it is impossible to keep two different precepts both at the same time. Sometimes a lie may be more compassionate than the truth. Sometimes a theft may save a life. Sometimes a mean act may preserve a resource vital to a greater good. Often it is not even that clear, because the future is never completely predictable. Deeds done with the best intention sometimes yield unfortunate results and the converse also does happen. 

For this reason, it is said that the precepts are koans. They are inherently insoluble spiritual problems that nonetheless repay the effort we put into trying to solve them. In the process we encounter vitally important learnings about ourselves.

Even so, as I said earlier, some skill in logic can be a considerable aid in freeing ourselves from error. Let’s look at an example. You may have heard the following argument before.

“There are no moral rules that are universally true. Morals differ from one culture to another. What is considered right in one place may be wrong somewhere else. Realising this we should learn tolerance. Everyone should respect the values of others.”

In this little speech, the first and last sentences are mutually contradictory. If one is true then the other is false. The assertion that everyone should do X is a moral rule that claims to be universally true. If there are no such rules then there is no basis upon which to assert what everyone should do.

I think we can see from this little example how easily we fall into self-contradiction, often with no consciousness of having done so. We think we are being logical, that our premises are self-evident and our conclusions, therefore, irrefutable, yet in just a few sentences we produce an absurdity. All this illustrates human fallibility. 

It also illustrates the complexity of the world. The imperative that one be logical and consistent rests upon an a priori assumption that the world itself is consistent. This is a priori in that there is no empirical way to demonstrate that this is the case. We assume it to be true but even if we are convinced that it must be so over-all in the universe as a whole, when it comes to circumstances in any isolated locality, inconsistency seems almost inevitable. In cosmic terms, a “locality” could be, for instance, planet Earth. 

It may be, therefore, that our minds are full of inconsistency because this is the character of the world around us. To live in harmony with our surroundings may, in fact, not mean being logical and consistent at all. Or, to look at the same thing the other way about, it may be that the only true consistency lies in having a completely cosmic “God’s eye” view, which we can conceptualise in principle but never realise in fact, 

Views: 113

Replies to This Discussion

Dear Dharmavidya,

Perhaps this "daily teaching" has been posted here in Archives because it is an archival piece? The other daily teachings have been posted under "Buddhism". For those of us following might it work to have a new section just called "daily teachings" or something similar. This would facilitate readers locating each day's teaching. I look forward to each posting and don't want to miss any! Thank you.

The individual teachings are posted according to subject, usually in Buddhism or in Hallenica, but sometimes a teaching does not fit neatly into one or other of these themes and goes somewhere else. However, if you do not want to miss any, you will find that there is a listing of all the Daily Teachings with links which you can access from the sub-tab that appears when you take your cursor to the tab Daily Teachings. You can also access the same backlist via Information.

.

No idea. Take your cursor to the tab Daily Teaching at the top of this page. When the cursor is over the tab a drop down menu of one item will appear with the word Backlist. Click upon it and you will go to http://eleusis.ning.com/notes/LIST_OF_DAILY_TEACHINGS where you will find a list. Yes? No???

Ah, right, yes, found it. Thanks. I'd been looking at the right hand column. Thanks!

You have clicked on the Event "Daily teachings" in the right column, not on the tab at the very top of the page, in the top margin above the header picture. Scroll up to the very top and you will find the main navigation tabs for getting to different parts of the site.

Thank you

RSS

Events

ITZI Conference 2019

Subscribe to ITZI Conference Newsletter

* indicates required

Blog Posts

Sagesse féline...

Posted by Tamuly Annette on September 29, 2019 at 12:00 1 Comment

En l'absence de Darmavidya, j'ai - en ma qualité de voisine et d'amie - le privilège de m'occuper (un peu) de Tara, la petite chatte. C'est un bonheur  de la voir me faire la fête chaque fois que je me rends à Eleusis: elle s'étire, se roule sur le dos au soleil ou saute sur mes genoux. J'ignore si elle a profité de l'enseignement du maître des lieux, mais j'ai comme l'impression qu'elle me donne une belle leçon de sagesse: elle…

Continue

WEEP FOR OUR WORLD

Posted by David Brazier on August 20, 2019 at 21:38 2 Comments



At the moment I am feeling very sad for the state of the planet. As I write the great forests are being consumed by fire, both the tropical forest in Brazil and the tundra forest in Russia. The great forests are the lungs of the earth. I myself have lung problems. When there are parts of the lungs that don’t work anymore one can run out of energy. It can strike suddenly. We will probably not do anything serious about climate change or wildlife extinction…

Continue

MY MEDICAL CONDITION

Posted by David Brazier on June 26, 2019 at 18:04 10 Comments

My medical condition continues to be a mystery. It is clear that I do not have any of the big nasty things - brain tumour, cracked skull, stroke, etc - as these have been ruled out by MRI investigation. Nonetheless I continue to have persistent, continuous head pain that varies in intensity and I become exhausted by the least effort so that I am functioning like an invalid incapable of doing very much. There is always a possibility that the whole syndrome is a…

Continue

Grace.

Posted by Dayamay Dunsby on June 2, 2019 at 1:02 4 Comments

“Do we know what it means to be struck by grace? It does not mean that we suddenly believe that God exists, or that Jesus is the saviour, or that the Bible contains the truth. Grace strikes us when we are in great pain and restlessness. It strikes us when we walk through the dark Valley of a meaningless and empty life. It strikes us when we feel that our separation is deeper than usual, because we have violated another life, a life which we loved, or from which we were estranged. It strikes us… Continue

© 2019   Created by David Brazier.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service