The news today that the Trump administration is to withdraw all US troops from Syria and half of its contingent from Afghanistan is of great importance. This is the first president for a very long time to take the view that the USA does not have to police every world situation and, indeed, can no longer afford to.

There are sharp differences of opinion within the USA on this change of tack. Many want America to hang on to its dominant role. There are also paradoxes. The left may now emerge as the war party. People who in the past have seen American imperialism as a rightist policy may now be somewhat confounded and confused what view to take.

Trump was elected, inter alia, on a platform of troop withdrawal and was persuaded to keep troops in Syria and Afghanistan against his better judgement, but, presumably, now believes it is time to do what he thinks best even though it runs head on against the political establishment.

The withdrawal from Syria will have a number of consequences. It will probably lead the Kurds to make some kind of deal with Assad's government and this should lead to a stabilisation of the country. This means that

- the end of the Syrian war may well now be in sight. This could be good news for millions of Syrians including a great many who have become refugees.

- the Assad regime will be more secure. Some will lament this as the survival of an autocrat. Others will say that this is the only way to have stability in such a turbulent region.

- the Russians will have made a considerable step forward in consolidating their influence in the Middle East. To many Arabs, the Russians will now appear to be more effective and reliable allies than the Americans.

- the policy of fermenting "Arab Spring" uprisings now appears to have had rather poor overall results with defeat in Syria, military take over in Egypt, chaos in Libya, and the great wave of refugees in Europe.

Partial withdrawal from Afghanistan will probably lead to some further advance of the Taliban and, possibly, growing Russian or Pakistani influence in the country.

Nonetheless, this could also be a step toward letting Middle Eastern countries sort out their own affairs, which ultimately could be to the good, leading to a balance of power more in keeping with the realities on the ground.

When we take stock, the supposed aim of establishing "freedom and democracy" does not look that convincing. Has it just been a cover for promoting certain interests? The West's strongest allies in the region have not consistently been the democratic ones.

Trump can, perhaps, be seen as acting as a business man. He has taken over America Inc and had a look at the accounts, seen a big pile of debt and a number of loss making projects and is making cuts. Many great countries in history have been bankrupted by involvement in wars. It is an open question whether Trump is saving the USA from a similar fate or jeopardising vital US interests. It is also an interesting question whether this is leading us toward a multi-polar world politically.

Views: 77

Replies to This Discussion

Of course, many previous presidents have said that the USA will withdraw and it has not happened, so we have to wait and see what the reality turns out to be.

If USA does withdraw, another corollary is that it will add weight to those who favour the creation of a unified European military.


The UK leaving the EU also makes this more likely and possible. Big questions will then arise about how it is to be led/controlled. Generally speaking it is the head of state who is the commander in chief of the military. This is one of the main reasons for having a head of state. The EU does not have one. Simply creating a "minister of defense" begs the question. An army led by a committee tends not to be very decisive or effective. This all, therefore, adds to pressure for constitutional reform in the EU. A new treaty would presumably be required. In present political circumstances, this might be difficult to achieve. One can, however, imagine progressive steps toward it if there were sufficient agreement between the biggest players.



ITZI Conference 2019

Subscribe to ITZI Conference Newsletter

* indicates required

Blog Posts

Sagesse féline...

Posted by Tamuly Annette on September 29, 2019 at 12:00 1 Comment

En l'absence de Darmavidya, j'ai - en ma qualité de voisine et d'amie - le privilège de m'occuper (un peu) de Tara, la petite chatte. C'est un bonheur  de la voir me faire la fête chaque fois que je me rends à Eleusis: elle s'étire, se roule sur le dos au soleil ou saute sur mes genoux. J'ignore si elle a profité de l'enseignement du maître des lieux, mais j'ai comme l'impression qu'elle me donne une belle leçon de sagesse: elle…



Posted by David Brazier on August 20, 2019 at 21:38 2 Comments

At the moment I am feeling very sad for the state of the planet. As I write the great forests are being consumed by fire, both the tropical forest in Brazil and the tundra forest in Russia. The great forests are the lungs of the earth. I myself have lung problems. When there are parts of the lungs that don’t work anymore one can run out of energy. It can strike suddenly. We will probably not do anything serious about climate change or wildlife extinction…



Posted by David Brazier on June 26, 2019 at 18:04 10 Comments

My medical condition continues to be a mystery. It is clear that I do not have any of the big nasty things - brain tumour, cracked skull, stroke, etc - as these have been ruled out by MRI investigation. Nonetheless I continue to have persistent, continuous head pain that varies in intensity and I become exhausted by the least effort so that I am functioning like an invalid incapable of doing very much. There is always a possibility that the whole syndrome is a…



Posted by Dayamay Dunsby on June 2, 2019 at 1:02 4 Comments

“Do we know what it means to be struck by grace? It does not mean that we suddenly believe that God exists, or that Jesus is the saviour, or that the Bible contains the truth. Grace strikes us when we are in great pain and restlessness. It strikes us when we walk through the dark Valley of a meaningless and empty life. It strikes us when we feel that our separation is deeper than usual, because we have violated another life, a life which we loved, or from which we were estranged. It strikes us… Continue

© 2019   Created by David Brazier.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service